Brian Rhea Brian Rhea

Are You Building a Vitamin or a Painkiller? Why Painkillers Always Win

Last week, I was recording an episode with Jane Portman for my podcast (stay tuned for links and release dates) and as we were talking about moving on from a previous early-stage startup she’d built and sold, she said something that jumped out at me:

“I realized that the product was a vitamin, not a painkiller.”

- Jane Portman

What a perfect analogy to keep in mind as you’re working on your startup.

Most people know they should be taking vitamins. They’d probably even tell you, “Yes! I would love that!” during customer discovery.

For example, the One-A-Day multivitamin that you and I both ought to be taking sounds incredible!

MedTech Startup: “Imagine that I could help you improve heart health, maintain healthy blood pressure, support your immune system, strengthen your bones, and increase your energy. And here’s the best part! It’s all contained within a single pill that you take once in the morning!”


Jobs to Be Done Forces of Progress

Everyone two weeks later:

Jobs to Be Done Forces of Progress

The thing is, people set reminders to take their vitamins, but they keep painkillers close at hand.

You don’t have to be reminded to take an Excedrin. You reach for it when you’ve got a headache.

With a vitamin, you have to introduce the customer to some non-urgent problem in the future (important as it may be) and convince them that your pill is the solution.

It’s not impossible. There are plenty of successful vitamin companies.

But which would you rather try to sell? A vitamin that people turn to when they remember they should be taking it? Or an Excedrin they keep in their purse, bag, nightstand, glove box, and overnight kit?

Telltale Signs Your Startup is a Vitamin

Earlier this year I was working with a founder who’d already built about 85% of a fairly complicated product. We were doing a batch of customer interviews and every now and then the participant would say something that tangentially related to the software the founder had already built. The founder’s ears would perk up and she’d point to the phone and nod emphatically to those of us in the room. “Yes. That right there! That’s it!” she was trying to say.

“Ohhhh dear,” I thought.

If you’re doingcustomer researchNeed a Stellar Jobs to Be Done Survey? Here’s How to Create One!Learn to design a JTBD survey, download a JTBD survey template, and prioritize your product roadmap effectively. Discover how to utilize the Jobs to Be Done approach for understanding customer needs with our step-by-step guide. and you find yourself convincing the prospect that they’ve got a problem you can solve, chances are you created your solution too early and you probably created a vitamin.

Yes, the problem might exist. Yes, you may have found a way to address it. But, if you’re getting excited every time you catch just a glimpse of the problem in your customer’s workflow, that could be a bad sign.

Look for Signs of a Headache

Customer-centric research goes in search of a problem first. I won’t belabor the metaphor, but it’s a lot more like seeing someone pinching their forehead and groaning rather than pleasantly going about their day with a slight Vitamin C deficiency.

To discover the pain and then design a way to solve it, you need to run some high-impact customer interviews and listen to the customer without searching for validation of what you’ve already built.

Claire and Gia over at have a killer webinar to help you know which tools to use, which questions to ask, and which questions to avoid.

And if you’re still uncomfortable running these interviews after watching that video, shoot me an email let me know where you’re stuck.

What Do You Think?

Are some vitamins worth building? What are other distinctions between SaaS products that are vitamins vs painkillers?

FREE Resource to Accelerate your Research!

In this guide, I share highly effective prompts for:

  • Defining the AI's role
  • JTBD statements
  • Forces of Progress
  • JTBD Timeline
  • Job Map
  • JTBD Canvas

    We respect your privacy. Unsubscribe at anytime.

    I've helped business leaders in Product, Design, Engineering, Sales, and Operations acheive their goals.

    “Hire Brian Rhea. The dude is seriously creative.”

    Brad Feld
    Managing Director, Foundry Group

    “Working with Brian has been a gamechanger for us! He takes the guesswork out of innovation research!"”

    Sabine Müller
    Research & Insights Lead, LEGO Ventures

    “Brian is the most gifted product strategist I've worked with in my career, and the things he taught us greatly impacted how I think about venture building today. He's extremely professional, very pleasant, and reliable.”

    Anders Søndergaard
    CEO, Coana

    “Brian is a genius. The thoughtfulness and creative leadership he brings to a team is unparalleled.”

    Andy Stone
    Director of Digital Experience, NetApp

    “Brian's skills and ability to innovate on the fly repeatedly pushed our projects farther than I thought was possible.”

    Brett Wagner
    Founder, Sidecar

    “Brian is one of the most creative thinkers and doers that I know. His ability to generate a concept and then follow through with the execution is admirable. If Brian is on a project, you can trust in the quality and delivery of his participation.”

    Brian Dodds
    VP Sales, Dash Solutions

    “Brian is a superstar. He is wicked smart, compassionate, able to distill complexity into manageable parts and to lead us through JTBD in ways our team could understand.”

    Ed Kacic
    President, Irvine Health Foundation

    “Brian is one of the most discriminating product professionals I know. He's developed a methodical framework for evaluating what features should belong in a product and what features should be killed.”

    Jason Hall
    Managing Partner, S&H Captial

    “Brian is a true visionary with a passion for excellence, knowing and communicating current and cutting edge technology and driving exceptional business results for clients. His exuberance and passion for creating and collaborating with his clients is outstanding!”

    Jeff Hughes
    Creative Design Director, United Airlines

    “Brian is the master of taking a fresh idea, distilling it to its core, and packaging it perfectly for users.”

    Jeff Stephens
    Director of Engineering, ONEHOPE Wine

    “I have always been impressed by the quality of Brian's work, the personal relationship he fosters, the value, punctuality and creativity he brings to every project.”

    Mark Stone
    Founder, The Info Group

    “Brian is a leader among leaders, a brilliant product thinker, and a genuinely good man. I hope you have the chance to interact or collaborate with Brian - you will be better for it.”

    Mike Taylor
    Head of Client Experience, Real Kinetic

    “Brian is the most gifted JTBD expert with whom I have had the opportunity to work. He brings a deep and intuitive appreciation for the outcomes that a user is trying to achieve. Brian's methodical and thoughtful approach to developing applications is rare and incredibly valuable.”

    Ryan Hunter
    Chief Revenue Officer, Spherex

    Ready to level up your product?